The airplane doesn't know you're an amateur

Created yesterday
by RSS Feed

Tags:
Categories: HeliNews Headlines
Views: 29
At 3:47 in the morning on May 22, 2025, a Cessna Citation S550 was flying the RNAV approach into Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport in San Diego. Weather at nearby Miramar, about four miles north, was half a mile in fog with an indefinite 200-foot ceiling. The airport's automated weather system was out, and part of its approach lighting had been out of service since 2022.The NTSB's preliminary report says the jet crossed a fix 2.9 nautical miles from the runway about 190 feet below the published minimum, then struck power lines 1.8 nautical miles out and came down in a Navy housing neighborhood. All six people on board died, and eight people on the ground were hurt. The airplane belonged to its pilot, a 42-year-old music agent who was authorized under an FAA exemption to fly the two-pilot Citation alone.Seven months later, on December 18, a Citation II owned by a company of former NASCAR driver Greg Biffle took off from Statesville, North Carolina, on a personal flight to Sarasota. Biffle was in a rear seat, not at the controls. The pilot in the left seat held an airline transport pilot certificate, and his Citation type rating required a second-in-command. His son sat in the right seat. Within minutes the crew reported instrument problems and tried to return. The jet struck the approach lights short of the runway, killing all seven on board. The NTSB's preliminary report found that the person in the right seat, with about 175 hours in single-engine airplanes, was not qualified to act as second-in-command.Both accidents are still under investigation, and I will not guess at their causes. But the FAA has already drawn its own conclusion. On September 29, 2026, it ended four decades of single-pilot exemptions for the transport-category Citation 500 series. It cited both crashes, falsified training records at some providers, and 18 years of accident data that, in its analysis, show these jets crash at about twice the rate of Citations designed for one pilot when flown solo. NBAA and Citation Jet Pilots dispute that data and have asked the FAA to release it. FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford has said the dialogue can continue.The two cockpits shared dissimilarities but had one thing in common. One airplane was flown by its owner alone, under an FAA exemption. The other was flown by an airline transport pilot whose type rating required a second pilot, with a right-seat occupant who was not qualified to be one. Neither airplane knew the difference. Weather, physics and a dark runway treat everyone the same. That is the problem this article is about.What the numbers sayThe good news first. General aviation is safer than it has ever been. AOPA's latest Richard G. McSpadden Report, covering 2024, found the overall accident rate fell to 3.69 per 100,000 flight hours, down from 3.86 the year before. The fatal accident rate fell to 0.57. Of the 1,064 accidents in total, 164 of them were fatal.Now the part that has barely moved in decades. In non-commercial fixed-wing flying, about 70% of accidents are still pilot-related. Loss of control, on the ground and in the air, remains a leading contributor to both fatal and non-fatal accidents. Weather-related accidents remain among the most lethal. The airplanes keep getting better; the human in the left seat is still the weak link.The most telling comparison is not between airplanes but between kinds of flying. When NBAA published the comparison, using 2011 data from the firm Robert E. Breiling Associates, corporate flying, with two-pilot professional crews, had an accident rate of 0.061 per 100,000 hours. That was better than the airlines' 0.175. Personal flying ran at more than 12 per 100,000 hours.Those figures are old, but the lesson has not changed. Corporate flight departments fly many of the same jets and turboprops that owners fly. The difference is not the hardware. It is how the pilots are selected, trained, checked, coached and supported, every single day.Why the usual model fails owner-pilotsI have spent my career on both sides of this divide, flying private jets and airliners alongside pilots from more than 65 nationalities. In the airline world, training never stops. You fly with a different captain or first officer every month, you are checked in the simulator twice a year, your flights are monitored through flight-data programs, and standard operating procedures shape every phase of every flight.Most owner-pilots live in a very different world. A typical pattern looks like this:Training is built around passing a test. The goal is the checkride, the type rating or the insurance requirement. Once it is signed off, training stops.Recurrent training happens once a year. Many owner-pilots, and plenty of Part 91 operators, send their pilots to the simulator once a year and fly the same profile every time.The profile is mostly engine failures. Year after year, pilots practice flying on one engine. But engine failures are not what kills most GA pilots. Loss of control, continued flight into bad weather and unstable approaches do.Nobody flies with them in between. For the other 364 days, the owner-pilot is alone, with no one to notice that standards have drifted.The executive mindset comes along for the ride. Many owners are successful because they are decisive and make things happen. In a cockpit, those same instincts can turn into get-there-itis, pressing on into weather to make a meeting, and a reluctance to say no.The result is a pilot who is legal and current but not necessarily proficient, and certainly not coached. Experience in other aircraft is no substitute for recent, specific practice in the airplane you actually fly.Pilots need coaching, not just testingThe core idea is simple: owner-pilots don't need more testing; they need ongoing coaching to give them what airline pilots take for granted, their own training department.Think of how elite sport works today. Professional teams employ sports scientists who track every athlete's training load, sleep, recovery, fitness and mindset, then plan training to avoid injury and peak on match day. Coached pilots can do the same, with one objective: safe, peak performance on every flight, for the whole of a pilot's flying life.In practice, that means:Get a personal coach, for the long term. Find a coach who builds an individual training plan, holds regular coaching calls and flies with you, in your own aircraft, to keep standards from drifting.Apply airline methods to private flying. Bring the training methods, standard operating procedures and crew discipline of Boeing and Airbus operations into your turboprop or light jet. If you want to go further, an airline type rating can deepen your knowledge and experience.Train in scenarios built around how you actually fly. If you fly into Aspen every winter, build scenarios around Aspen, including the conditions that have caused accidents there. Much of this can be done on fixed-base simulators, which cost far less to run than full-motion devices, so you can train more often.Practice upset prevention and recovery in real aircraft. Once a year, take upset recovery training in real jets with qualified instructors, including training to manage the startle effect.Train the whole pilot, not just the hands. Grade yourself across five domains: attitude, situational awareness, communication, optimization and technical knowledge. Fitness, sleep, nutrition and mental wellbeing are part of airmanship, because a tired, stressed or distracted pilot makes worse decisions.Never stop learning. Make time for regular webinars led by experienced airline pilots on topics such as winter operations, weight and balance and unstable approaches.None of this replaces the FAA's minimum standards. It builds above them. The minimums tell you whether a pilot is legal. Coaching is what makes a pilot good, and keeps them good.If you're buying an airplane or learning to flyIf you are shopping for your first airplane, or thinking about learning to fly so you can fly your own, here is my advice. Approach it differently from the way most people do.Plan the pilot before you buy the airplane. Decide what kind of flying you want to do in five years, then build a training path to get there. Too many pilots buy the airplane first and try to grow into it.Train to a professional standard, even if you'll never fly for pay. Learn standard operating procedures, checklists and callouts from day one. Habits formed early are the ones that hold under pressure.Treat the checkride as the start, not the finish. A new certificate or type rating is a license to keep learning. Budget for training every year, not just for the airplane.Train more often than once a year, and for what actually goes wrong. Ask for scenarios built around your airports, your routes and your weather, not just the standard engine-out profile.Fly with a coach. Have an experienced instructor fly with you in your own aircraft regularly. A second set of eyes catches drift you will never notice yourself.Look after the pilot, not just the airplane. Sleep, fitness, stress and fatigue affect your decisions as much as your stick-and-rudder skills.Set personal minimums, and write them down. Decide in advance what weather, runway and fatigue limits you will accept. Then keep to them when the meeting, the family or the weekend is waiting.The Citation single-pilot ruling, contested as it is, is a reminder that if the industry does not raise its own standards, the regulator may do it for us. Owner-pilots have the chance to get ahead of that, by choosing to train like professionals because it is the right thing to do.Fly like a professionalOwning and flying your own airplane is one of the great freedoms in aviation. It also makes you the chief pilot, the training captain and the safety department of your own flight operation. The airplane will never know you are an amateur. The only question is whether you fly like one.About the author: Fabrizio Poli is the founder of Airavat Aviation Group, which trains pilots from their first lesson to the most advanced level and coaches owner-pilots to airline standards. He has flown private jets and airliners worldwide, founded BizJet TV, and is the author of the books The Quantum Economy and Be Aware But Don't Care, both available on Amazon.